From early February through late March, 1941, Italian and Royal Colonial troops staunchly defended the Eritrean city of Keren against British Commonwealth forces. The Italians had retreated east to the highlands around Keren after being defeated in late January at the Battle of Agordat. Keren offered the Italians the last feasible chance at retaining the vital Eritrean port city of Massawa.
At Keren, the landscape favored the defenders. A virtual amphitheater of jagged mountains ringed the city. The most strategic point in this landscape was the Dongolaas gorge to the southwest of Keren. This was the easiest route into the amphitheater—but it was also the most easily defended. To secure the ravine, Italian forces had blocked it with boulders and mines.
In the rocky, dry heights, defending troops were unable to dig-in, and there were no fortified emplacements or defensive buildings. The Italian and Royal Colonial units benefitted from crags and rocky positions transformed into effective defensive strongpoints; these units were also determined not to succumb.
In the final phases of this long battle, Italian forces north of Keren were successful in defending against an advance from the 13th Demi-Brigade of the French Foreign Legion. General William Platt, commanding Commonwealth forces, posited that the Dongolaas gorge southwest of Keren was the weak point in the Italian lines.
The Commonwealth offensive from Southwest of Keren through the ravine began on March 15, and met stiff opposition. The Italians used mortars, artillery, and buried incendiary devices to stop British tanks attempting to advance up the Dongolaas road.
Commonwealth units had more success the next day. In response the Italians pushed back with sustained assaults for a week that succeeded in halting the advance.
Shortly thereafter, Commonwealth officers decided to send sappers up the Dongolaas gorge to clear obstacles, while infantry units advanced into the surrounding hills to ensure this work could be done free of interference from mortar and machine gun fire.
Before dawn on March 25, Commonwealth forces moved through the Dongolaas gorge in conjunction with a hundred-gun suppressive artillery barrage against Italian positions on Mt. Sanchil. Within a few hours, Commonwealth forces had secured the north side of the ravine to shield the sappers, who advanced to clear the roadblock.
With the road cleared, early in the morning of March 27 elements of the 5th Indian Division advanced south of the ravine while artillery began to rain down on the Italian positions on the heights of Mt. Zeban and Mt. Falstoh. By first light, these positions were untenable, and the Italians began to fall back toward Keren.
At this point the Matilda II tanks and motorized infantry of Fletcher Force proceeded through Dongolaas gorge toward Keren. The 4th Indian Division, meanwhile, advanced up the heights toward Mt. Sanchil. The defenders found themselves surrounded. By the evening of March 27, the Keren stronghold ceased to exist. Commonwealth forces now had a clear road to the port city of Massawa.
The Commonwealth victory at Keren turned out to be the keystone of the Allied offensive in East Africa. Italian and Royal Colonial forces did not break down after receiving extensive aerial and artillery bombardment as they had a few weeks previously at Agordat; rather, over the course of weeks of incessant combat, they gradually dissolved from near-constant area attacks and periodic fanatical counterattacks.
In a battle that ultimately lasted fifty-six days, Italian and Royal Colonial troops defended resolutely. Despite this resistance, Italian forces lost the battle—and in so doing, lost the province of Italian East Africa. This time, can the Italians turn the tide and repel Allied forces, or will they again suffer catastrophic defeat?
“Do not let anybody think this is going to be a walk-over. It is not. It is going to be a bloody battle: a bloody battle against both enemy and ground. It will be won by the side which lasts longest. I know you will last longer than they do. And I promise you I will last longer than my opposite number.”
General William Platt, British Army
Commandant, Sudan Defence Force, 14 March 1941
Commonwealth Forces | Italian and Royal Colonial Forces | |
Division 1 |
Div 1 Element 1: Elements of the 4th Indian Infantry Division 4 Squad Bases 1x Alpha Unit (1 star) Div 1 Element 2: Sappers and Miners 3x Engineer |
Comprised primarily of the 11th Black Shirt Legion “Consul Ugo Gresele” and 10th and 11th Regiments Savoia Grenadiers, plus artillery units. Div 1 Element 1: 11th Black Shirt Legion 1x Bravo Unit (1 star) 1 Cannone da 47/32 mod 1935 anti-tank gun Div 1 Element 2: 10th & 11th Reg’t Savoia Grenadiers |
Division 2 |
Div 2 Element 1: 2nd Battalion West Yorkshire Regiment and 3rd Battalion 5th Mahratta Light Infantry 4 Squad Bases 1x Alpha Unit (1 star) Div 2 Element 2: 2nd Highland Light Infantry, 4th Battalion 10th Baluch Regiment, and 3rd Battalion 2nd Punjab Regiment 4 Squad Bases 1x Alpha Unit (2 stars) 2 Bedford OY Transport |
Comprised primarily of elements of the 6th, 12th, 16th, 41st, and 61st Colonial Battalions, plus artillery units 5 Squad Bases 1 Cannone da 47/32 mod 1935 anti-tank gun |
Strategy Decks | Artillery 1 Morale 1 (see Special Rules) Desert Tactics 1 (shared) |
|
Starting Strategy Cards |
4 In Play Area |
4 In Play Area |
Starting Command Points |
2 |
3 |
Operations Cards | none | 013 Desperate Defenders 014 No surrender 017 Camouflage |
Deployment Zone | Div 1 Element 1: Any hexes on Map 18A Div 1 Element 2: Any of the first three Road hexes from the west on Map 19A Div 2 Element 1: Hill hexes south of Dongolaas gorge on Map 14A Div 2 Element 2: Any of the westernmost two rows of complete hexes on Map 19A |
Div 1 Element 1: Any Hill hex on Map 20A Div 1 Element 2: Any Hill hex on Map 17A Div 2: Any hex on Map 15A, plus the grey-bordered hexes on Maps 13A and 21A |
Starting Initiative | Setup First | |
Objective |
Commonwealth forces must capture and hold both Objective Markers by the end of Round 7, otherwise the Italians win. |
|
Rounds | 7 | |
Actions per turn | 3 | 3 |
Reinforcements |
Round 2 (Status) placed at the orange “R” hexes on map 19A. 3x Recon 3 Bren Gun Carriers |
Status Phase of the Round in which Commonwealth forces capture the Victory Objective Marker in map 14A, placed at the grey “R” hexes on maps 13A or 15A. Round 3 (Status) Lancia 3Ro trucks
|
Special Rules |
Available Command Command Point (CP) Markers Incendiary traps Avalanche roadblock Hill hexes & overlays Cover provided by higher elevation Inherent anti-tank gun crews Concealment of anti-tank guns Cover for anti-tank (AT) guns Entrenchments Morale Deck |
|
Special Rules (units) |
Commonwealth initiative Fletcher Force Central India Horse Royal Air Force (RAF) superiority |
Cannone da 47/32 mod 1935 anti-tank gun Regia Aeronautica Lancia 3Ro trucks Black Shirt units Carro Armato M11/39 tanks |
Terrain Features | ▪ Hex overlays (from Base game, Days of the Fox, and Normandy sets) - 1 quadruple Hill - 1 quadruple Double Hill - 1 single Dune - 1 single Rough - 1 single Rough + Road - 1 triple Clear - 1 single Clear - 4 single Building - 6 single Hill - 2 double Hill - 2 triple Hill - 5 single Road ▪ 12 Entrenchments ▪ 1 Minefield ▪ Markers - 2 1-pt British Command - 1 2-pt British Command - 3 1-pt German Command - 4 1-pt Neutral Command - 3 Victory Objective |
Designer's Note
The motivation for creating this scenario came from the observation that when design started in 2020, there were no ToI scenarios set during the period January through March 1941. This period witnessed some significant battles in East Africa; this scenario attempts to address this gap.
As of August 2023, I had play tested this scenario in solo play about five times. It could probably use some additional play testing from other people.
This is the first ToI scenario I designed, and after play testing it started to dawn on me that I may have made it overly complex. I was trying to model a real battle as best as could, while also using specializations that do not often get used, introducing new units, and adding some new scenario-specific mechanics.
Italian reinforcement by the Carro Armato M11/39 tanks represents commitment of the few armored vehicles they have remaining in-theater. In actual fact, the Italians did not use these tanks during the battle. The Italians had stationed them about 120 miles east at the seaport of Massawa and destroyed them upon surrendering in early April.
This scenario requires the base game and Days of the Fox (original or Next Wave).
Sources
“Battle of Keren,” Wikipedia, available at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Keren, accessed Jan. 20, 2020.
Gianmaria Spagnoletti, “Italian Resistance at the Battle of Keren,” Commando Supremo: Italy at War, March 2002, available at https://comandosupremo.com/battle-of-keren/, accessed Jan. 17, 2020.
Jim H., “Camicie Nere: Blackshirts MVSN & CCNN,” Commando Supremo: Italy at War, March 2010, available at https://comandosupremo.com/blackshirts/, accessed Jan. 17, 2020.
Jim H., “Cannone da 47/32 mod 1935,” Commando Supremo: Italy at War, March 2010, available at https://comandosupremo.com/cannone-da-47-32/, accessed Jan. 17, 2020.
Jim H., “Fiat M11/39 Tank Details and Specs,” Commando Supremo: Italy at War, March 8, 2010, available at https://comandosupremo.com/fiat-m11-39/, accessed Mar. 2, 2020.
“Lancia 3Ro,“ Wikipedia, available at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lancia_3Ro, accessed Jan. 17, 2020.
“Central India Horse,” Wikipedia, available at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_India_Horse, accessed Jan. 20, 2020.
Italian Initiative Card
1941 propaganda poster calling on Italians to avenge their defeat in East Africa.
Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Cartolina_Ritorneremo.jpg.