Evert and I wanted to have another go at this scenario. This time, the French advanced slowly and the 'square' flattened out into a line, while the Austrians organised themselves into a defensive line. Then the French left flank launched an assault, cavalry hitting the end of the Austrian line while the infantry hit Süssenbrunn town, taking out the Grenadiers holding it. 0:1 to the French.
The Austrian muskets quickly exacted revenge, eliminating a French Line infantry. And General MacDonald. That's 2:1 to the Austrians. More intriguingly, that seems to destroy the 'square'. [Since infantry units are only part of it while contiguous with MacDonald, that clearly can't happen now, so bang goes the special rule.]
Fighting continued around Süssenbrunn for some time with both sides taking heavy losses. The Austrians lost two more Grenadiers and Line infantry, while removing two more French Line. That's 4:4 and the French cavalry on the left flank is behind the Austrian lines. The other cavalry then attacks centre-right, eliminating the Austrian Cuirassiers to make the score 4:5.
The Austrian horsemen responded by taking out the French Heavy cavalry (5:5). The French cavalry then finished off the Line infantry they'd been toying with (5:6). And General Vudassovich failed to escape through their ranks: 5:7 and a French win.
I think Evert made better use of the 'square' initially, but the loss of MacDonald early on meant that it didn't last long. That was a good fight that lasted 23 turns in all and took 90 minutes or so.
Swapping sides a week later saw an early success for Evert's Austrians, removing two units from the 'square' with the first exchange of fire (lucky dice from Evert).
I regrouped the 'square' as a compact group and continued pushing forward and left towards Süssenbrunn. The French infantry took out an Austrian Line infantry while cavalry occupied Breitenlee town on the left: 2:2. The Austrian Grenadiers promptly eliminated another French Line for 2:3.
The 'square' pushed on, taking Süssenbrunn only for General MacDonald to fall (again!) with his infantry. That's 3:5.
The score evened up when the French infantry continued to advance on the left and removed a Line infantry and Grenadiers. And destroying the rest of the Austrian right flank (left on the board) gave the French another win 7:5.
That was a faster game at 19 turns taking just over an hour. And we had two French wins, both 7:5, which means the aggregate score is 12:12 and a draw!
I’ve also posted this report on my BGG blog (with pictures!):
boardgamegeek.com//blogpost/181776