Scenario: 213 Camalatrum (71 BC) 

Deadline:  31/05/2018

Player 1 Game 1 Game 2 POINTS Player 2 Game 1 Game 2 POINTS
Carthage  6 6 3 scipio1zama 2 0
g1ul10 6 6 3 Cavie 1 2 0
Tomek 6 6 3 Polonus100 4 1 0
BrentS  6 6  3 LeonardoAngelo  5 1 0
stormwalker  6 5  2 Mark-McG  4 6 1
toganalper 0 4 0 mk20336 6 6 3
EZPickins     1 sduke12     1
Nemo2333 6 3 1.5 Mad Doc 3 6 1.5
talonz 3 1 0 Armada01 6 6 3
Stanislav27 0 gottoman 6 6 3
Gonzo     1 IvanSirko     1
gcallari  resign resign 0 CrimsonCobraX     3
Gleam13 resign resign 0 ympytyar     3
Prof X     PCScipio42     1

Round 3 Results

 

Player

Score

Strength

1

Carthage

9

14

2

g1ul10

9

10

3

Tomek

8

13

4

BrentS

7.5

10

5

scipio1zama

6

16

6

mk20336

6

13.5

7

stormwalker

5.5

10.5

8

Cavie

5

17.5

9

Armada01

4.5

15

10

Polonus100

4.5

14

11

gottoman

4.5

11.5

12

Nemo2333

4.5

10.5

13

Mad Doc

4.5

9.5

14

Mark McG

4

19.5

15

LeonardoAngelo

4

17.5

16

EZPickins

4

15

17

sduke12

4

13

18

ympytar

4

12

19

CrimsonCobraX

4

8

20

toganalper

3.5

14

21

Gonzo

3

10.5

22

talonz

2.5

12

23

Ivansirko

2

10.5

24

Prof X

2

9

25

Stanislav27

1.5

16.5

26

PScipio42

1

15.5

 

gcallari

Resigned

 

 

Gleam13

Resigned

 

 

 

Good luck, and any questions please send me a PM or email

 

Log in to comment

Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
results are up now
BrentS replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
Sorry, Michal, the plan had been to show the rankings after every round but I think it's difficult to tabulate on the website (it is for me, at least). What I'll do is attach the last two rounds' rankings as Word documents in the thread for the next round.

Brent.
mk20336 replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
Hi Mark
Where we can see the standings after round 3?
Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
I'm afraid time marches on, and so must the tournament.
IvanSirko replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
Couldn't play with Gonzo yesterday due to internet connection on his end. Wrote to Mark. Waiting for responce.
Armada01 replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
Game 1
Talon (Slaves) - 3 banners
Armada01(Rome) - 6 banners

File Attachment:

File Name: TAlonzvsTo...me1.vlog
File Size:34 KB


Game 2
Talon (Rome) - 1 banners
Armada01 (Slaves) - 6 banners

File Attachment:

File Name: TAlonzvsTo...me2.vlog
File Size:28 KB
Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 10 months ago
several results outstanding, and the deadline is looming. Please get you matches played ASAP!
gottoman replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Game 1
Greg O (Slaves) - 6 banners
Stanislav27 (Rome) - 1 banner

Game 2
Greg O (Rome) - 6 banners
Stanislav27 (Slaves) - 4 banner
g1ul10 replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Game 1
Giulio (Slaves) - 6 banners
Cavie (Rome) - 2 banners

Game 2
Giulio (Rome) - 6 banners
Cavie (Slaves) - 1 banner

It was a long time I did not play with Dan and I was looking forward to it. If I'm not wrong, the last time he beat me badly at battlelore :-) This time was different but, especially in the second game, I have to admit that I was helped by extremely lucky rolls! Dan played well, as usual. But cards and dice were on my side.

File Attachment:

File Name: Giulio_Cav...me1.vlog
File Size:33 KB


File Attachment:

File Name: GiulioCaviegame2.vlog
File Size:41 KB
Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
so long as they get it done by 31 May, I'll score it.
That being said, they both currently score 3 points each this round, so one of them, and maybe both could lose out here in tournament points.
OTOH, not playing for sheep stations
LeonardoAngelo replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Tomek is right. That's a great idea, my friend. CrimsonCobraX and ympytyar - maybe you will really play with each other?
Tomek replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
I have a proposal regarding the "withdraws" from the tournament. If I am not mistaken we have two people resigning at this round. Instead of giving automatically 3 points to their opponents, perhaps they can play against each other. After all we are doing it for fun and glory, right?
LeonardoAngelo replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
I wanted to say that the player "Gleam13" is also likely to withdraw from further competition. I asked him to unsubscribe in the subject yourself. Perhaps he will do so in the near future.
Thus I propose to charge a technical defeat, and his opponent - 3 points.
Mad Doc replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Game 1
Mad Doc (Slaves) 3 banners
Nemo2333 (Rome) 6 banners
Game 2
Mad Doc (Rome) 6 banners
Nemo2333 (Slaves) 3 banners
Tomek replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago

File Attachment:

File Name: ot3mt.vlog
File Size:27 KB

File Attachment:

File Name: Camala2.vlog
File Size:36 KB
Game 1
Tomek (Slaves) - 6 banners
Polonus100 (Rome) - 1 banner
Rome lost by somehow reckless advance of the main body and complete lack of fortune. Cactusus and Spartacus joined forces and annihilated almost the entire legion by series of devastating attacks.

Game2
Tomek (Rome) - 6 banners
Polonus100 (Slaves) - 4 banners
This battle was more balanced and disputed. The ferocious attacks of the slaves almost broke through. Three entire units were destroyed with single attack. Funny challenge was to command the main roman force in the centre without having a single command card for the section during the game.
Carthage replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Game 2
scipiozama (Slaves) 5 (29 blocks lost)
Carthage (Romans) 6 (23 blocks lost)

File Attachment:

File Name: ot2018scipio.vlog
File Size:30 KB
Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
I should add that Gabriele has withdrawn for the rest of the tournament. So down to 27 players now!
CrimsonCobraX replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Round 3 CrimsonCobraX vs gcallari
"Hello Anton,

I am terribly sorry to let you know so late but I cannot play this afternoon. I am also afraid I probably cannot go on with the tournament at all, so please accept my apologies"

gcallari forfeited
stormwalker replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Round 3 Mark McG vs stormwalker

Match 1
Mark McG (Roman): 4 banners
stormwalker (Slave Army): 6 banners

This battle played out in a rather typical manner. The battle began with a perhaps too confident attack on the Marcius forces. The Roman units in the north were finally killed off but managed to take with them 2 Slaves units and forced Castus to run off the battle field. Then the battle moved to the centre-right section were both sides gained banners in succession. Finally, the battle was decided by an attack of a single Slave light infantry unit on a lonely Roman general.

File Attachment:

File Name: OT2018_Cam..._G1.vlog
File Size:35 KB


Match 2
Mark McG (Slave Army): 6 banners
stormwalker (Roman): 5 banners

This was a very unpleasant battle for the Romans. With a well-prepared attack in the centre the Slaves manged to obtain a very quick 4-0 lead leaving the Romans in a state of despair. But since in CCA every banner counts the Romans carried on: counter attacked in the centre dispatching two Warrior units and occupied the Slave camp in the north killing another 2 units in the process. At this point the result was 5-5. In the last turn the Slaves faced a dilemma: should they try to take back their camp or simply try to gain the final banner? Since taking camps is not at all straightforward, the Slaves went for the final banner and secured the victory.

Due to a laptop crash we lost our only log file for this battle. Below you will find two .vsav files showing the location of our units in the last two turns.

Many thanks to Mark for playing!

File Attachment:

File Name: OT2018_Cam...2_1.vsav
File Size:11 KB

File Attachment:

File Name: OT2018_Cam...2_2.vsav
File Size:11 KB
mk20336 replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Round 3 Camalatrum (71 BC)

Game 1
ToganAlper (Romans): 0 Banners won
MichalK (Slave Army): 6 Banners won

This scenario is usually decided on Marcius/Castus wing. It was like this also in that case. I managed to encircle Romans there and score full 5 banners not losing a one. That means that getting the last one was only a matter of time. Togan had awful cards (two MC, two Order Heavy) and I kept constant pressure on him so he really did not have time to free up his hand.

File Attachment:

File Name: OT2018_R3_G1.vlog
File Size:24 KB


Game 2
ToganAlper (Romans): 4 Banners won
MichalK (Slave Army): 6 Banners won

Immediately after first game we initiated second one. Again, Marcius/Castus wing was crucial. Couple of initial moves were preparations for encircling and cutting to a piece the Romans in corner but I decided to change the momentum and attacked with double time. In the end I lost 4 banners there, but managed to take 3 for me, including Castus itself. Lucky Marcius escaped.

Then is was war of position and maneuver, which also due to some unlucky rolls of Togan I managed to in.

File Attachment:

File Name: OT2018_R3_G2.vlog
File Size:33 KB


Two exciting games of very difficult (especially for Romans) scenario.
mk20336 replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago

Mark-McG wrote: "Mark for choosing such an interesting scenario."
- involved around 30 seconds thought prior to heading to work.. you're welcome..


That is what they call "efficient decision making" :laugh:
Mark-McG replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
"Mark for choosing such an interesting scenario."
- involved around 30 seconds thought prior to heading to work.. you're welcome..
BrentS replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Round 3 Camalatrum

Game 2
BrentS (Slaves) 6
LeonardoAngelo (Romans) 1

A very different game to the first. The Slaves had time to get Castus' isolated right flank units and a Warrior unit from their left to join Cannicus' force around the camp, closing the net around Marcius' troops. Too late they realised the danger and started moving but the slaves sprung the trap....all 4 Roman units killed for the exchange of a single Slave warrior and Marcius forced to make a leader escape through the hills.....which he survived! A Slave Light Cav which had been waiting patiently in the forest shot a 1 block Roman light which was sheltering on the Roman baseline. Crassus formed his lines and advanced toward Spartacus in the hills on the less threatening Slave left but in so doing his exposed left flank had to cross in front of the Slave camp, where Cannicus and Castus were reforming their troops. The warriors Double Timed into an unsupported Roman Medium and killed it, taking the last banner and routing the Roman army.

Thanks to Leonid for a couple of very entertaining games and to Mark for choosing such an interesting scenario.

File Attachment:

File Name: CCAOT18R3B...lo2.vlog
File Size:39 KB
Carthage replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago
Game 1
scipiozama (Romans) 2 (21 blocks lost)
Carthage (Slaves) 6 (17 blocks lost)

File Attachment:

File Name: ot2018scipuio.vlog
File Size:24 KB


While the Slaves get into position the Roman lights inflict heavy casualties to Cannicus skirmishers and even completely destroy Spartacus light cavalry after it foolishly got its retreat path cut off by warriors and the Lucanian Lake. Castus takes the iniative and attacks Crassus centre force. The Roman riposte is hindered by the Roman light caught in the midst of the fight. Castus forces manage to eliminate the Roman force but Crassus escapes but chooses not to flee and take the rightern forces to push back. Castus suffers heavy losses and seeing that his contingents end is eminent goes for one last decisive charge in which they kill Crassus and an infantry regiment.
BrentS replied the topic:
5 years 11 months ago

File Attachment:

File Name: CCAOT18R3B...lo1.vlog
File Size:44 KB
Round 3 Camalatrum

Game 1
BrentS (Romans) 6
LeonardoAngelo (Slaves) 5

Spartacus with a Warrior unit and some lights outflanked the Roman right and killed my poorly positioned cavalry and Light Infantry while Crassus Double Timed into the leaderless Slave centre, followed by a Clash of Shields which took out a couple of Slave units, knocked another couple down to 1 block, sent S[partacus fleeing and looked like the end game.....except that I was completely unable to order my centre for the rest of the game! The Slaves took advantage and put me down 5 banners to 4. With no other option I was forced to assault the left flank hills with the advance force there, repositioning Marcius onto the Auxilia. Castus went for him in the hills and lost out and next turn I was able to occupy the camp with Marcius and the 1 block Auxiliary for an unlikely win. The game ended bizarrely with a bunch of scattered Roman Mediums adjacent to 1 block Slave units that they'd be keeping company with for the last 5 turns.....given the Slaves' inability to press advantage against my paralysis in the centre, I assume they had no centre orders either. An interesting, non-linear brain-burner of a scenario and a fun, close match that could have gone either way. Well played by Leonid.

Edit: I didn't realise Leonid had already reported this, so this is a double up of the first match, Mark. Leonid, by convention the match winner reports, unless otherwise arranged, to avoid confusion.