Welcome to the Samurai Battles forum!

Tell us and our members who you are, what you like and why you became a member of this site.
We welcome all new members and hope to see you around a lot!

VASSAL Tournament

More
9 years 4 weeks ago - 9 years 4 weeks ago #170 by toddrew
Replied by toddrew on topic VASSAL Tournament
While I wouldn't mind a do-over ;) , this was round 3 - it was the other Todd playing, toddrew, not plainscape.

Even though overall the dice results fit the Imagawa side's intentions better than Oda's, the cards were the killers. Oda had no center cards for the start, and made the decision to take a flag instead of let the arqy's pound away at the Naginata. This lead to a couple of early loss of honor rolls and too long to mount any sort of offensive. By the time the opportunity did arise for Oda to exert some control over the game, the losses from the ranged attacks were too great to expect victory for Oda: A two figure Imagawa Naginata went up against a two figure Yari unit of Oda, the dice failed the Oda unit. First Strike was played (as much for a chance at a draw of useful card as a way to hopefully avoid an attack), but no hits, and the battle back took the Oda unit and the leader chose Seppuku rather than suffer another loss of honor roll.

Slim hopes after that for Oda, all dashed by untimely rolls and relatively vicious battle backs by the Imagawa archers and arquebuses.

After four rounds of overall fortuitous dice, felt I had this one coming :pinch: Well played by SM - strength of the Imagawa army was the range and position, and both were handled deftly.

Oh, and I don't think I've ever been a part of a C&C game where one side was so overwhelmingly defeated - of the 35 figures Oda began the game with, only four were on the board when the game ended.
Last edit: 9 years 4 weeks ago by toddrew.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 4 weeks ago #171 by squatting monkey
Replied by squatting monkey on topic VASSAL Tournament
Yes, sorry, it is Toddrew; I've corrected the post.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 3 weeks ago #172 by theimann
Replied by theimann on topic VASSAL Tournament
Imagawa Player (Squatting Monkey): 0 banners won, 10figures lost
Oda Player (theimann): 5 Banners won, 5 figures lost

After an all out charge on the Command tent, the Imagawa Clan was lost. Without any luck or cards to move their reserves into the mix, once the command tent was lost, all was lost. In my opinion this scenario is very unbalanced. even moving the Command tent back or moving the Red reserves up one row might make a difference.
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 3 weeks ago - 9 years 2 weeks ago #173 by goshublue
Replied by goshublue on topic VASSAL Tournament
Round 1 - Azukizaka 1

BrentS (Imagawa) Banners 5 - Figures 8
Plainscape (Oda) Banners 1 - Figures 20

Closer than it looks from the banner count. The Oda beefed up their hand with a White Dragon and gave the Imagawa a fright by using a Serpent Command and Move Like the Wind to bring their whole centre against the Imagawa left. Some lucky rolls, a timely and successful Revenge kill by an Ashigaru Bowman against the Oda cavalry and two Cavalry Charges saw the Imagawa come out as victors. The other flank saw little action except for a single volley of arrows and some skulking in the forest and neither Commander's repose was disturbed in their tents.

Brent.
Attachments:
Last edit: 9 years 2 weeks ago by goshublue. Reason: Added log file

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 3 weeks ago - 9 years 2 weeks ago #174 by goshublue
Replied by goshublue on topic VASSAL Tournament
Round 2 - Azuki-Zaka 2

BrentS (Imagawa) Banners 6 - Figures 15
Ben (Oda) Banners 3 - Figures 27

This was a great game, a bloody struggle that involved all three sections equally. Two First Strikes. Four dead leaders (this game is SO harsh on them), one of Ben's losing despite 8-5 odds in a Personal Challenge he'd issued (how often does that happen?). I spent a lot of time hovering just above zero H&F but was never forced into a Loss of Honour roll.

Good stuff.

Brent.
Attachments:
Last edit: 9 years 2 weeks ago by goshublue. Reason: Added log file

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 2 weeks ago - 9 years 2 weeks ago #175 by goshublue
Replied by goshublue on topic VASSAL Tournament
Round 3 Okehazama - Border Fort Marune

BrentS (Imagawa/Red) Banners 5 - Figures 7
Mark McG (Oda/Yellow) Banners 2 - Figures 22

This one is quite unbalanced and I can't see Oda winning without wild luck……they're fighting for as many banners as they can score here and Mark did well in a controlled fighting withdrawal. Leader kills on either side and both cavalry wiped out. The Arquebus units were key contributors, taking out two Oda units, one being the coup de grace on Oda's most important unit, the cavalry….Fire by Rank is crazy good (I hadn't noticed the exploding swords clause before). Another good bang for buck Dragon Card is Timid Success, which prevented the Oda cavalry from advancing and left it stranded in the Arquebus killing ground. Two Infantry Onslaughts into the Oda left, one with an Ashigaru Attack, finished it.

This battle highlights a different dynamic in Samurai Battles. A lot of these battles the enemy is in your face quickly and you're milling H&F and Dragon Cards. In a longer. slower build up like this, H&F and Dragon Cards really accrue. By late game I had H&F in the high teens and at one point I think I had 8 Dragon Cards to choose from. This is a dynamic that interests me from a design point of view (I think lower starting H&F and Dragon Cards is probably the way to go in these sorts of match ups).

Brent.
Attachments:
Last edit: 9 years 2 weeks ago by goshublue. Reason: Added correct log file

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 1 week ago #177 by g1ul10
Replied by g1ul10 on topic VASSAL Tournament
Round 3 Okehazama - Border Fort Marune

Giulio (Imagawa/Red) Banners 5 - Figures 16
Theimann (Oda/Yellow) Banners 2 - Figures 20

Thomas had to go and forfeit the game to me. We agreed on a final score of 5-2. I report the figures count as it was at the moment he left the game. Thomas played very well in a definitely unbalanced scenario. As usual, I'm not particularly satisfied by my performances. In my defence I can say that my initial hand was pitiful. Basically I always lacked the cards to effectively attack or react.
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 6 days ago #178 by g1ul10
Replied by g1ul10 on topic VASSAL Tournament
Round 5 007 Domyoji (1615) - Heights of Komatsuyama

Giulio (Imagawa/Red) Banners 6 - Figures 17
sammysnijbonen (Oda/Yellow) Banners 3 - Figures 22

Again a horrible initial hand! (I know, I'm becoming annoying...) I've been ambushed, first struck, afflicted by rice famine and by the spirit of the white fox. At the very end of the game I lost a leader in a personal challenge remaining with 3 cards. Add to this pitiful dice rolls for several turns BUT I scored 3 hits battling back against Ben's cavalry and this was enough to win. Ben exploited my weaknesses. I felt the pain of all his Dragon Cards. Great game.
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
9 years 6 days ago - 8 years 11 months ago #179 by Mark-McG
so with 23 games played, the Semi-Finals are now determined

Red Semi-Finals
BrentS vs Cavie

Yellow Semi-Finals
toddrew vs plainscape

Scenario
008 Domyoji (1615) - Battle Among the Tombs
Red Semi-FinalGame 1Game 2Total
Brent156
Dan538
Yellow Semi-FinalGame 1Game 2Total
toddrew459
plainscape538

“I dreamt of worldly success once.”
― Miyamoto Musashi
Last edit: 8 years 11 months ago by Mark-McG.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
8 years 11 months ago #327 by Cavie
Replied by Cavie on topic VASSAL Tournament Semi-Finals
008 Domyoji (1615) - Battle Among the Tombs (Semi Final Games for Brent & Dan)

Game 1
Osaka (Red/Dan) Player: 5 Banners won
Tokugawa (Yellow/Brent) Player: 1 Banner won

Game 2
Osaka (Red/Brent) Player: 5 Banners won
Tokugawa (Yellow/Dan) Player: 3 Banners won

Both great games with Brent as always. In Game 1 Brent pressed early on his Tokugawa's left with what should have been better results. Instead the Osaka right got the better of the battle. This made for an early banner lead and tough chance for comeback. The dice continued to favor the Osaka and ended in a 5-1 loss for the Tokugawa.

Game 2 was looking good for the Osaka again but this time the dice favored the Tokugawa's leader checks. 2 killed leaders sealed the banner count but the Osaka prevailed to win the game.

Really enjoyed the games once again and as I mentioned to Brent - I can NOT complain about dice ever again - at least here on Samurai Battles ;)
Attachments:

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 1.697 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum