Retreating to Corners

More
5 months 4 weeks ago #1158 by Mark-McG
I've been loooking at some scenarios for the 2nd Crusade, which generally ended badly in Western Anatolia.

A problem with the scenario set is that they are generally very similar, Turks ambush the Crusaders as they try and cross a pass or river. I feel like scenarios should have a quirk or character to them, making them  a little different from the others, and for this scenario I've tampered with the retreat rules, which has all sorts of ramifications, which is what I'm asking here about. Essentially, I'm changing the Turk baseline to the 4 corners of the map. The Turks retreat, evade and feign retreat towards the closest corner.

 
Special Rules
• Seljuk Units retreat, feign retreat and evade towards the closest Rally Point. In event of a tie, the Turk player chooses.
The retreat distance is as normal, but the path must always shorten the distance to the Rally Point marker. If the unit cannot so shorten the distance, it loses a block for each retreat hex it cannot fulfill.


so the question is, how comprehensible is the Blue text to you?

the addendum question is, are their other times that the baseline is relevant other than Retreat, evade and feigned retreat. 

For clarity, the Crusaders retreat normally, towards their baseline.

wise and full of devices

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
5 months 3 weeks ago #1161 by Freeloading Phill
Seems fine to me.
May want to restate that the path must allow the full retreat, to stop any argument of intent to allow it by omission, i.e. no choosing a blocked path to take blocks and remain close.

And I like the scenario variety this brings.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
5 months 3 weeks ago #1162 by Mark-McG
Replied by Mark-McG on topic Retreating to Corners
  • When a unit can retreat legally, toward its Rally Point, without taking block losses, it must take this retreat path instead of a retreat path where a block loss would occur
paraphrases the written rule.

Definitely a Special Rule I would use again..  potentially with an alternative of a Rally Point in the Centre for those Hattin like surrounded scenarios.
 

wise and full of devices

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 1.666 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum